Marshall had been nominated for three other awards. He lost Best Male Vocalist to Jarrett Rollins of the band Crazyheart – the group to which The Hillbilly Souls also lost Best Country Band Live. Crazyheart now has won the award for at least the past nine years. Rollins also won Best Entertaining Duo with Bonnie Rollins.

Beating out Marshall and The Hillbilly Souls for Best Original Band was Groovitude, in a tie with Psych. Groovitude also won Best teenage band or soloist (not associated with an organization or school) for the second year in a row, and Best Overall CD for "Wildfire."

Groovitude was the only other act besides Marshall and Conklin to individually win more than two awards. Popular cover band The Large Flowerheads won for Best Cover Band and the top band category, Best Entertaining Band, and its drummer, Maureen "Mo" Jerant tied for Best Drummer.

Gospel singer Ian Holmes, a former "American Idol" contestant, won for Best Male Vocalist on the industry ballot, and Best Gospel/Contemporary Christian Music Soloist. His Holmes Family group won for Best Christian Band, and his sister, Kari, from that band tied for Best Spoken Word.

Blues man James Supra continued the awards' only unbroken streak of wins in a category, winning Best Harmonica honor for the 13th year in a row.

Conklin actually won the night's first four awards, and won every category for which she was nominated.

For Best Blues Vocalist, she beat Sarah Ayers, who started performing again after a year off for throat surgery. Before the year hiatus, Ayers had won 24 awards in three years, and won the industry's Best Female Vocalist at least seven years in a row.

"I'm just so amazed," Conklin said. "The Lehigh Valley Music Awards truly wants to bring out the best talent in the Lehigh Valley. Tonight I've seen more and more artists I never knew existed. This is the best of the best. I'm so amazed, I had forgotten I was even nominated."

Conklin also brought Domina on stage and asked the audience to give her a standing ovation, which they did.

Longtime favorite Steve Brosky won Best Singer/songwriter on the industry ballot. Best New Artist went to 5 Ton Jack.